Original comment · Local permalink · Archive observation: 2015-03-23 01:41:43 UTC
Again?
This readable transcript was assembled from public Arctic Shift archive records on 2026-10-18. It preserves recovered wording and parent/reply relationships; it is not a screenshot of Reddit and does not reproduce Reddit's voting order or interface. Images and linked websites are not automatically copied. Record observation dates can differ.
125 recovered comments · 1/1 cited comment IDs recovered.
Original Reddit thread · Provenance and coverage · Normalized transcript
Raw archive responses: post · comments-tree
No text body was recorded. This may be a link post.
Original linked destination: http://deskdroid.com
Again?
[deleted]
How does it compare to EasySMS?
EasySMS requires (afaik) USB or Wifi connection, or at least a lot of configuration.. DeskDroid just works out-of-the-box over the internet, anywhere.
You convinced me. Are you the creator of the app?
Great! Yes, I am.
Does this work the same way as "remote web"?
I'm at the "collecting messages" screen, been here for like 10 minutes now on my nexus one. In a future update you might want to setup a progress bar. I figure this is something you only expect people to see 1 time, so didn't think much of it. But it's people's first impression. Luckily i'm pretty patient so i'm going to wait it out. But i'd bet you'll save yourself a lot of 1 star reviews if you just put something there showing progress
A progress bar is on the list. Thanks for you suggestion. It will come in a release soon.
I've been waiting for this app for a long time. Bravo.
Thank you! Please remember to rate it in Android Market :)
I'd like it if there was a client app for my nook to send messages via my phone, rather than having to jump on a site in the browser, log in, send a message.
Good suggestion! We are working on a desktop client for Windows, Mac and Linux, but tablet editions is also a great idea.
You got a mouse in your pocket?
I got more than one ;)
Yeah if I could get access from my archos 101 that would be awesome
my phone explorer does thia
There should be a Market link on the page, also in the email. QR codes are second to Market links these days! Also, why is there a need of username. Isn't email enough?
There is a market link on the frontpage. Username might not be needed, this might be changed in the future.
Even if username is used in the future, please do not use it for sign in. Use email instead.
Its no really working on my og droid running project elite. I'm on wifi to maybe make it easier. It will send messages but not receive them and it doesnt have the messages with my contacts. If i want to send a new text i have to delete what i sent last time and just press enter and it'll send.
Please try again. One of the fixes we have just deployed might fix this too. If it still does not work, please send an email to [email protected]. Thank you :)
But you're essentially giving a third party rights to send SMS messages from your device, right?
Not something I'd be too happy with really.
I have to agree. Once the product is direct to phone I'll consider it. I'm not setting my phone up to be a potential spam launch point.
Nope, SMS messages are sent to and from your own device. No other have access to neither your phone, sending messages from it or anything else. Your messages and device is completely yours. DeskDroid is just connecting to your device when you log in, so you can use your browser as an interface for sending and reading SMS through your own device.
You're giving DeskDroid (a third party) access to send SMS messages via your device. How else does it work?
I'd need to trust DeskDroid and (probably more importantly) the security they implement on their site a lot before I'd open up access to my phone.
Edit - just realised that you are the author of the application. Not trying to piss on your parade here, just giving honest feedback. But that would be my main concern, security.
Thanks for your comments. Security is, and should always be taken seriously. From the bottom up, we have been working on making DeskDroid as secure as possible. We will soon implement SSL for encryption of all communication and the site. Likewise, all information in databases are encrypted, to make sure that no wrong person can get access to wrong data or devices. But again, thanks for pointing this out, as it is really important!
sounds awesome :) once SSL is implemented, ill definitely be downloading this app!
SSL is implemented now :)
I just signed up and it emailed me my password in plaintext. Please fix this.
Thanks for your suggestion! It is fixed now. It no longer sends password in the signup mail.
Cool, that was quick. But are you still storing it in plain text?
Also, I'm signed in and trying to type in a contact name into what I'm assuming is the "To" field, but it keeps replacing what I'm typing with "Home()". I'm on Windows 7 SP1 32-bit, Chrome 10.0.648.204.
Edit: in case anyone is reading this, this was resolved after logging out and logging back in. Otherwise using DeskDroid has been a pleasure so far.
Nope, it is not stored in plain text. Neither is messages or any other sensitive data. I just tested it out again in Chrome on Windows 7, and I don't seem to get any problems. Could you please send an e-mail to [email protected], if you still got problems? Thanks :)
So you only store the hash of the password now? That's what he was afraid of, since you had the ability to send out the password by email.
Only a hash, yes. The email is sent out during the signup-process, before the hash is generated. That is why :)
One small thing, the automated email sends this:
>Your username is Valsung and your password is what you chosed when you signed up.
Chosed sounds silly. Chose is past tense as is.
Thanks, my bad. It is corrected :)
Just checking that it's a salted hash. If it's not, you may want to start salting them.
It is.
Signed up but won't let me log in, says password is incorrect, and it won't email me a new password. Any chance you can reset mine? Username is the same as my reddit name.
Hey Kris, you should have received a new e-mail now. If not, please send a mail at [email protected]. Thanks :)
[deleted]
Awesome, thanks. On with testing this out!
I use Texdro. The free version allows you to send and receive texts on your computer as long as both your phone and computer are on the same network. I think the paid version allows sending and receiving via USB and Bluetooth http://www.appbrain.com/app/texdro-desktop-sms/com.crackedsun.texdro
Have you tried both? Which is better?
Cool product, except right now when I click send it is stuck at "sending..."
EDIT Win7 Chrome 12.0.733.0 and Firefox 3.6.13
Hey alec, please try stopping and starting DeskDroid on your phone, and make sure that it is connected to the internet. If you still have problems, please send a mail to [email protected]. Thanks!
that worked, thanks
Just wondering, how do you plan on getting revenue from this?
Right now, DeskDroid is free. We are working on a lot of other features, like MMS, photo/video download from phone, backup of messages and the phone, a desktop/tablet client and a lot of other things. At some point, we will make it possible to upgrade your account, to get access to all of these features.
ic thats pretty cool. BTW, im setting it up right now, i think it will be useful for me when im at home...how much data will it use (i mean data/text), and i noticed it syncs my contacts as well as all my previous texts.
how often will it sync my contacts (i mean will it sync all my contacts every hour, thereby using up data?
It will only sync once, when DeskDroid is started on the phone. After that, messages are only synced when it is sent or received, and only that one message. Contacts are currently only synced on startup.
It's a bit slow (hangs on Sending sometimes) but other than that, good work! First message I sent was sent twice, not too sure why. I may have accidentally clicked it twice? Maybe you should put in some 'spam-protection' so to speak so you can't accidentally do this?
Also, after you send a message the character-count still counts whatever length your just-sent message was, instead of resetting itself (it then resets itself as soon as you start typing).
Good work.
Thanks for your feedback! It is currently hosted in Ireland, which my be the reason why it can be a little slow some places in the world. A spam protection is a good idea. I will put that on my list :) The character-count-bug is now fixed. Thanks for pointing that out!
Might just be my internet, I'm in South England.
Wow, that was fast! And I confirm that the character-count-bug is fixed :D Keep us all updated on your progress. :)
You could try connecting your phone through wifi, and see if that helps. Thanks, will do! I will also be posting information about new releases and updates at the Facebook page - http://www.facebook.com/pages/DeskDroid/210353455658709
Appears to hang on sending for me too. I'm getting replies to messages I sent, but the webpage still says "Sending".
Windows 7 64-bit/ Firefox 3.6.16
We are working on making messages move to the list instantly so that it is not necessary to wait for it to send, and on improving connectivity, so that these errors/problems do not appear. Until then, if you have a problem with messages not getting sent, please restart DeskDroid on your phone, and refresh the browser. Thanks :)
Tried it earlier today out of curiosty - doesn't seem to be working at all though. All the web interface tells me is the no. of messages on my phone, that's it. Running on a Galaxy S with Darky's ROM 9.3 - incompatible or I'm doing something wrong?
Hey, If you click Messages in the topp menu, you should be able to see all of the messages on your phone. If not, please send an e-mail to [email protected] with information about which browser and OS your are using, so that we can fix any errors that might be. Thanks! :)
Crosstxt does the same thing, but it's in closed beta.
EDIT: Sticking with crosstxt. It alerts you when you get new messages, has a chrome extension to give you desktop alerts when you get new messages, and doesn't force close. It also lets you control your information, you can delete messages/contact information off their servers.
Thanks for your comment. We are working on a desktop client for Windows, Mac and Linux, that will be in the system tray to inform you when new messages arrives, and let you respond the same way as in the web interface.
This is all that I could really hope for as an extra feature, glad to hear you're working on it.
It came integrated with PDAnet tethering, it was pretty nice to not have to answer from a phone while on the computer.
I so want source for this, year ago or so I was looking at prices for website/text integration, I think I've just seen an option for the cheapest unlimited texts plan I can find(probably about £5/month, less than 1/3 of the cheapest plan, and with more control too).
Will this app be continuously running in the background of my phone? And if so, will it be eating a bunch of my battery?
It will be running in the background on your phone, yes. But fortunately, it will not eat up your battery, as it is only active very briefly when you send or receive a message. We have tested it out on multiple devices, and has not found that it is using battery notably.
Great, thanks for the quick reply. Looking forward to testing it out more.
Can I use this without an internet connection? My phone has crappy wifi connections to my router for some reason and I don't have 3G.
You can use it with either Wifi or an internet connection like 3G. USB and Bluetooth is not, and will not be supported. However, you can connect your phone to the internet through USB, and use it that way.
How is this better than Google Voice?
Well, the same way as apples are better than oranges. It is a different application, with different features. DeskDroid will in time be expanded to also cover backup, galleries and lots of other features. For now, the big difference is that you can manage messages currently on your phone (delete, read and so on), from the browser. DeskDroid is an interface to your phone :)
Google Voice can not receive SMS from email.
Where does this come into play? Any site that wants to send an SMS to authenticate an account. Take Facebook as an example. If you plug your google voice number into Facebook as a mobile, they will attempt to send an SMS to it for authentication.
With this app, the SMSes go through your phone, so you get all the advantages of a a real SMS message, plus the convenience of using your web desktop to send it.
I like PDANet for this same reason, though it does require a USB connection.
These really are two completely different services that have a function that somewhat overlaps. But if we try to compare, some other advantages this app has would be (probably) MMS - google hasn't added that feature to voice yet - and using it without switching your number. (This is just speculation - I can't test the app because I don't have a texting plan)
Voice has some advantages as well:
texts and calls archived in the cloud rather than on your phone
free visual voicemail
you don't lose the ability to send/receive texts on a different device if your phone is off
you can send/receive from any device with an internet connection and a browser without installing software
texts are handled as data, so you can save money by switching to GV and abandoning your texting plan
Google Voice doesn't work outside the US.
You can't use your existing phone number with Google Voice (while keeping your plan)
This seems like an interesting idea. Would it be possible to also send messages through Google Talk? I use the Talk desktop client a lot, and it would be nice to integrate both systems.
We are considering an idea like connecting DeskDroid to various IM networks, like Google Talk. More information will pop up later at the site and in newsletters.
Isn't this a less capable version of Google Voice?
Using Chrome 10.0.648.204 on Windows 7, and I'm getting a \ in front of all my single quotes every time I send a message from the website. E.g. "can't" becomes "can\'t"...kind of frustrating.
Edit: claification
Thank you for pointing that out. We will fix that problem as soon as possible.
Thanks! It's cool to hear from a developer so quickly.
One thing that would be nice would be if the favicon for the website changed to show new messages when they come in. Currently, instead of showing a favicon, on Chrome you get a spiny icon that never goes away, making it look like the page is never done loading. Perhaps there's some javascript or ajax causing that to happen?
Thanks :) Yes, good suggestion with the favicon. We are looking in to why it keeps spinning in Chrome.
Small suggestions. On the login screen, when typing my username/password, I like to use the hardware keyboard on my phone, when I slide out the keyboard the app stays in portrait mode, making typing a bit annoying. Be nice if it adjusted to landscape mode.
Thanks, I noticed that too. I will put it on the list :)
[deleted]
Please see my reply regarding this, above: It is a different application, with different features. DeskDroid will in time be expanded to also cover backup, galleries and lots of other features. For now, the big difference is that you can manage messages currently on your phone (delete, read and so on), from the browser. DeskDroid is more like an interface to your phone :)
Found a bug, it adds a "\" before an apostrophe for some reason.
For example, if I type: Hope you're having a good day.
It actually sends: Hope you\'re having a good day.
By the way, this is wicked fast, as soon as I hit the sending button it shows up on my phone (Evo on Sprint). I just wish it would say "message sent" instead of "sending".
Thanks for your comment. We are working on both issues, and will have it fixed within a few days.
Doesn't seem to update the messages i recieve on my phone and it is stuck on sendeing even if the message is alredy sent. But other than that nice app, i think i'll keep using it in the future.
It doesn't seem to work for me at all. I can try to send a message, but it won't show any of my previous messages in the box and it took at least 30 minutes to send a message to someone. Also on every page after it finishes loading chrome still has the little spinny loading thing forever.
Is it iPad compatible? If so, I'm sold. Glad someone is working on this.
can't get this working on Chrome 11.0.696.44 beta. just hangs when trying to Send a message from the web.
Hey all, We have fixed a bug that caused contacts not to be displayed. This is working now - it was a problem with contacts that contains special characters in their phone number (*#+ and so on). It should be working now. Also, if you like this application, I would be very happy if you would go to Android Market and rate it. Thank you :)
Just popping in to say it works great. Would love a chrome extension!
I backup my messages through "SMS Backup" — will messages that I send through DeskDroid be backed up? Essentially, where are the messages stored when sent through DeskDroid?
[deleted]
[deleted]
Whenever I start this application, I recieve force closes on "google services framework".
Could you please try starting the application, and send a report when asked? That way, we will be able to fix this problem. Thank you :)
Do people still use SMS?
I don't want to, but I have to say it: GTalkSMS does way more than this without the need to make an account.
Been waiting all day for the deskdroid site to load my contacts and msgs but it has not. I'm from australia and was wondering if this is why it is not working? Stuck on "fetching messages" status!!
It's runnin a little slow right now, but this looks like it has potential.
When I click on a persons name their messages never load. Tried on dev build of chrome, and IE8.
We will take a look at this, and get back to you. Thanks.
Some of my contacts have the number in this format ### ### ### When your app tries to send the sms, instead of sending to ######### it sends to ###+###+### and fails.
Thanks for your comment. We will get it fixed as soon as possible.
EDIT: It should be fixed now. Please let me know if you still have issues with this. Thanks!
I am going to try your app, but I do have to ask:
1 - How are you going to make money out of this? 2 - In what ways will you use the information stored in my phone?
Hello,
How does it compare to Texty
This is cool. My contacts don't seem to be appearing. They are stored on a gmail account. Any ideas?
We have made some fixes regarding this. Could you please send an email to [email protected] if you still got this issue? That way we can check if there is a problem and get it fixed. Thank you :)
Using a Nexus One on Gingerbread here, website hangs on 'Sending...' when I attempt to send an SMS.
Also, please implement SSL on your websites login ASAP :)
SSL is implemented :) Regarding the "Sending..." problem, we will be releasing a new version of the app later today, which should fix this issue.
Excellent job.
8 out of 10 messages it hangs at "Sending" - tried to reopen the app multiple times and my phone has a a steady connection to the internet.
When I send messages to myself - there are no problems.
Great idea though!
And now the app forceclosed - and havnt send out the last 3 messages. Server problems?
It seems to be misinterpreting my phone book entries. I.e., messages to +1 (212) 555-1234 is being sent to +1%28212%29555-1234.
Thanks for your comment. This is fixed now. Please let us know if you still have problems, at [email protected]. Thank you!
I really like the concept but it the web front does not work well for me at all...None of my contacts were listed, and half of the messages were all sent from "undefined" Also when I received a message when connected the web front end didn't update. When I went to refresh, I no longer got any messages listed. I'll try again in a couple months as this is definitely a problem I'm seeking a solution for and your app if working properly would solve it!
You can already do this via GMail if you have it enabled in Labs. No app required.
How, exactly? What lab option is this?
This is great! Any chance you'll expose an API? I could see some ideas for cool integration w/ other software if an API was available.
That's not impossible. If you would like to discuss this, please contact me through mail :)
UPDATE: SSL is now implemented at the website, so that all communication goes through HTTPS. This will also be added in the phone-application with the next release.